The Content Of The Article:
- Test winner in the folding saws: Gardena 200P
- 1st winner in the garden saws: Felco F630
- 2nd winner of garden saws: Fiskars SW-330
- Test winner in hack saws: Gardena Comfort 760
- Maintain branch saws properly
- How to find the right branch saw
- Folding branch saws in the test
- Bahco branch saw 396-JT
- Berger folding saw 64650
- Price / performance winner: Connex TurboCut branch saw
- Felco tree saw No. 600
- Fiskars Xtract SW75
- Test winner: Gardena garden folding saw 200P
- Silky F180 180mm folding saw
- Wolf Garden Folding Saw Power Cut Saw 145
- Garden saws in the test
- Bahco branch saw 5128-JS
- Berger Handsaw 64850
- Connex TurboCut branch saw
- Test winner: Felco F630 branch saw
- Test winner: Fiskars SW-330
- Gardena Combisystem Garden Saw 300 P
- Gardena Combisystem Garden Saw 300 PP
- Price / performance winner: Grüntek Barrakuda
- Silky 270-33 Zubat
- Wolf Garden Power Cut SAW 370
- Hacksaws in the test
- Bahco hacksaw Ergo
- Berger hacksaw 69042
- Connex branch saw FLOR74340
- Fiskars Hacksaw SW31
- Gardena Combisystem Hacksaw 691
- Test winner: Gardena 8748-20 Comfort Hacksaw 760
- Price / performance winner: Grüntek hacksaw Marlin
- Enter your e-mail address and download the test chart
- Worth knowing about the toothing of branch saws
- It's easier to cut with the right cut
A good pruning saw is part of the basic equipment of every garden owner. Therefore, we have in our large practical test 25 different branch saws in the three segments folding saws, garden saws and hacksaws by experienced hobby gardeners try and evaluate.
Most hobby gardeners still use their pruning saw mainly in the winter to pruning - while garden experts are now largely agreed that a summer cut has many advantages: First of all, the cuts heal faster, because the metabolism of the tree is working at full speed. The wounds are therefore less prone to fungal attack.
But there are also arguments for the winter cut. Above all, they are practical: on the one hand, the treetop in the leafless state is clearer and the elimination of the uncultivated clippings easier.
Incidentally, many work on the tree can be done comfortably from the ground - such as easy, plant-friendly and comfortable sawing with a branch saw on the telescopic handle. It should have a stable saw blade with double hardened saw teeth. Also recommended are additional features such as knots and Bindenanritzer.
By the way: As a rule, more than half of the cutting work is done with the pruning saw. The rule is: "saw first - then cut", i. old and stronger branches are sawn out in a first operation, only the subsequent "fine work" is done with the pruning shears or secateurs.
Test winner in the folding saws: Gardena 200P
Test winner in the category folding saws: Gardena 200P order at Amazon
The Gardena 200P achieved the deserved test victory in the popular segment of folding saws: it impresses with its ergonomics and cuts fresh wood quickly and precisely with little effort.
1st winner in the garden saws: Felco F630
Test winner in the category garden saws: Felco F630 order at Amazon
The Felco was high-quality processed and showed no weaknesses in handling. In addition, the storage holster was by far the best in the entire test field. Together with the Fiskars SW-330, which was placed at the same point, this was enough for the test victory in garden or reciprocating saws with a rigid saw blade.
2nd winner of garden saws: Fiskars SW-330
Test winner in the category garden saws (tied with the Felco F630): order Fiskars SW-330 at Amazon
Person zwischen person person person? Person person? Person person person?? ?Ts person? Person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen zwischen zwischen person zwischen zwischen zwischen person zwischen zwischen zwischen person zwischen zwischen zwischen person zwischen? Zwischen person zwischen? Person zwischen? Person zwischen? Person zwischen person zwischen person person zwischen? Person?? Person? Person?? Zwischen? Person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person person zwischen person person zwischen person person zwischen person person zwischen person person person zwischen person person person zwischen person person person zwischen person person person zwischen person person person zwischen? It is equally well suited for right and left-handers. The garden saw is on par with the Felco F630 and is the second test winner in this segment.
Test winner in hack saws: Gardena Comfort 760
Test winner in the category Hacksaws: Order Gardena Comfort Hacksaw 760 from Amazon
The saw blade of the rugged Gardena Comfort 760 hacksaw effortlessly ate through thicker branches and drier wood. The finger guard over the handle prevents impact injuries during sawing. Despite the rigid, non-rotating saw blade that was enough for the test victory.
Maintain branch saws properly
After sawing, not only does the cut of the tree have to be taken care of by cutting the frayed edges of the bark smoothly with a sharp knife. Person person person? Person? Person? Person zwischen person? Person zwischen person zwischen? Person zwischen? Zwischen person zwischen zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen person zwischen zwischentsts zwischen person person zwischen? Zwischents zwischents person zwischen person? Person zwischen? Person zwischen? Person zwischen? Person zwischen? Person zwischen zwischen person personts zwischents person person zwischents person zwischen person zwischen? Person zwischen person zwischen? Person zwischen zwischen person zwischents ?ts person person zwischen person zwischen zwischen? Zwischents zwischentststs person zwischen zwischen zwischen? Person? Person zwischents person zwischen? Zwischen person zwischen zwischentsts zwischen? Adherent resin dissolves well with vegetable oil - an effective and environmentally friendly method of cleaning the leaf of the branch saw. Aggressive cleaning agents, on the other hand, can attack the rubber handles. ? Person zwischents person??? Person? Person? Person? Person? Person? Person? Person? Person? Person?? Person person? Person ?ts person? Person ?tstststs persontstststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststststs person person personts zwischen persontststststststststststststs? The joint of the folding saws also needs every now and then a drop of oil, so that it remains flexible.
How to find the right branch saw
The selection of the right branch saw depends mainly on what tree care work you want to do in your garden. Therefore, those who do not have to cut large trees do not need a saber saw with a telescopic pole, but usually come with a handy folding saw. If you already own a telescopic handle, for example from Gardena or Wolf Garten, and use it with other tools such as a fruit picker, it makes sense to buy the right saw for this system.
Whether you opt for a fold-out pruning saw, a fixed, straight or curved saw, or even a hacksaw, you are left with a habit and a personal taste. If you have the opportunity to try different models before buying - for example, as part of a pruning course - you should definitely do this.When buying, do not necessarily go for the cheapest model, because the quality of the steel and the edge retention of the saw blade are often significantly worse for cheap models from the discounter. Among other things, good quality is recognized by the slightly darkened tips of the teeth - they are a sign that the steel has been heat-treated once more and thus hardened.
Folding branch saws in the test
Folding saws can be stored safely by their mechanism after use
Folding collars are the most popular for pruning. Although they are more suitable for smaller branches depending on the length of the saw blade, they have the great advantage of being able to fold the saw blade into the handle like the pocket knife and then store the device in the trouser pocket without any risk of injury. Folding pruning saws are reasonably priced due to their simple construction and the saw blades can usually also be individually purchased and replaced on higher quality models.
Here are the test results of the eight folding saw models, which we took a closer look at as part of our large branch saw test.
Bahco branch saw 396-JT
The folding Bahco branch saw 396-JT with the so-called JT toothing is particularly suitable for soft and green wood. The triple ground and resharpenable long teeth with small gaps have 45° grinding angle for razor-sharp cutting. The extra smooth surface is suitable for cutting fruit trees, vines and many other woody plants.
The Bahco 396-JT has a blade length of 190 millimeters
The Bahco folding saw has a two-component plastic handle that feels good and secure in the hand. The lock works very well with a thumb pressure with open as well as with closed saw. If necessary, the saw blade can be replaced quickly by loosening a screw. A manual was unfortunately not available on the shelf packaging in the trade. But you get several clicks on the website for a more detailed product overview.
The Bahco 396-JT has a saw blade length of 190 mm and weighs 200 grams. She receives a "good" from our testers with a total score of 2.1. With its price, it is in the upper midfield of the tested folding saws.
Berger folding saw 64650
The folding branch saw 64650 from Berger has, according to the manufacturer, a replaceable high-performance saw blade made of hard chromium-plated carbon steel for a long life of the blade and protection against corrosion. The triple-ground and pulse-hardened tooth tips work only on train and slide with minimal resistance through the branch. This allows for a precise, clean cut.
The saw blade of the Berger folding saw 64650 is replaceable
Due to the setting of the saw teeth a clamping of the branch saw is avoided during the cutting process. The hand-friendly handle of the Berger folding saw fits well in the hand and the safety catch can be easily operated with one hand. Information is unfortunately not available on the shelf packaging in the trade. But you can get a detailed product description via a QR code or via the website and several clicks.
The Berger 64650 has a saw blade length of 180 millimeters and weighs 210 grams. It is rated by our testers with an overall grade of 1.9 and thus a "good". Priced she is in the middle.
Price / performance winner: Connex TurboCut branch saw
Connex's Turbo Cut Cutter has a triple honed, hardened special toothing for a fast, smooth and clean cut in fresh and dry wood. Clamping during sawing avoids the hollow grinding of the saw blade. Above all, our testers described the safety of the saw as excellent.
The Connex TurboCut is available with 150 mm or 360 mm saw blade
With its two-component grip, the Connex TurboCut was good in spite of its weight in the hand. The safety lock can be easily operated with one hand. A sufficient manual is available on the shelf packaging in the trade. Much more information about the product is not available on the manufacturer's website either.
The Connex Turbo Cut has a saw blade length of 150 millimeters. She receives a "good" from our testers with a total score of 1.9. With a price of around 16 euros she is the Winner of the price / performance ratio.
Felco tree saw No. 600
The hinged Felco No. 600 with pulling cut has a saw blade made of corrosion-resistant chrome steel. The tips of the Felco were heat treated with high voltage pulses to cure. With this saw, we achieved a clean, precise cut. The conical shape of the saw blade did not even jam. Felco states that the shape and position of the teeth prevent the saw blade from crusting.
The Felco No. 600 has a saw blade with a pulling cut
The Felco No. 600 is maintenance-free and all parts are interchangeable. We really liked the comfortable, non-slip grip.The operating instructions are exemplary and comprehensively integrated into the shelf packaging in many languages. More information about the product is not available on the website. The Felco No. 600 was designed in Switzerland and is manufactured in South Korea.
The Felco No. 600 has a saw blade length of 160 millimeters and weighs 160 grams. She receives a "good" from our testers with a total score of 1.9. With her price she is in the middle of the field.
Fiskars Xtract SW75
The Fiskars Xtract SW75 is the largest hand saw in the test field and the only one that does not have a folding mechanism but a sliding mechanism: The saw blade is pushed in or out by pressing a rotary knob. An equally safe method as flaps. Fiskars believes that the roughing of this tree saw is the most effective way to cut fresh wood.
The Fiskars Xtract SW75 saws in the pulling direction
The Fiskars Xtract SW75 fits perfectly in the hand and the so-called SoftGrip handle also provides a strong grip. The downward curved finger guard prevents contact with the saw blade. The integrated belt clip is helpful when transporting the saw. The information on the shelf packaging in the trade can be used as a basis. But you get on the website with several clicks to a detailed product description.
The Fiskars SW75 has a saw blade length of 255 mm and weighs 230 grams. She receives a "good" from our testers with a total score of 2.1. With her price, she is in the upper midfield of the test group.
Test winner: Gardena garden folding saw 200P
The Gardena Garden Folding Saw 200P impressed our testers with its excellent ergonomics, high-quality materials and outstanding sawing performance with little effort. Here, the hard chrome-plated saw blade with its pulse-hardened 3-side precision tooth grinding shows its strengths. The branch saw cut off all branches clean. In particular, the sawing was pleasantly simple and accurate.
The Gardena 08743-20 Garden Folding Saw 200P has a slightly angled handle shape
The Gardena 200P can be locked in various positions as the only folding saw in the test field. The mechanism holds the saw blade firmly in all positions as well as in the folded state. The manual is extensively written in many languages and is included in the shelf packaging in the trade. More information about the product can be found on the website with three clicks.
The Gardena Garden Folding Saw 200P has a saw blade length of 215 mm and weighs 400 grams. Our testers chose them with a total score of 1.5 and the grade "very good" for the test winner.
Silky F180 180mm folding saw
Silky's Japanese F180 wing saw is a versatile pruning saw for various cutting operations in the garden. The compact F180 requires little power and makes it easy for the hobby gardener to work in the dense shrubbery. The stiff sheet with a pulling cut leaves a robust impression and is very well suited for fresh wood.
The Silky F180 180mm folding saw enables fast, clean cuts with little effort
The polypropylene handle has a rubber insert that absorbs vibrations. He seems a bit slippery. Wearing gloves is always recommended. With the locking mechanism, the Silky F180 saw blade can be safely locked in two different positions. A manual is in the shelf packaging commercially available only in English. But there is a small utility folder for all Silky saws in the packaging. You come across various detours on the website for a German description.
The Silky F180 has a saw blade length of 180 millimeters and weighs 150 grams. It was rated by our testers with a total score of 2.3 - a "good". Priced the folding saw is in the midfield.
Wolf Garden Folding Saw Power Cut Saw 145
The Wolf Power Cut Saw 145 has a strikingly ergonomically shaped handle with a pleasant soft inlay. Two so-called round stops on the front and back of the handle ensure good grip and safe handling.
The saw blade of the Wolf Power Cut can be adjusted in two different working angles
The two different working angles were considered useful by our testers for corresponding applications. The special drawing teeth of the Power Cut Saw 145 ensure powerful and fatigue-free working. The saw blade is easily replaceable if necessary. Information in the shelf packaging in the trade, unfortunately, only sparsely available. But you come via the website and a few clicks to a slightly extended product description.
The Wolf Garden Power Cut Saw 145 has a saw blade length of 145 millimeters and weighs 230 grams. She receives a "good" from our testers with a total score of 1.9. With her price she is in the upper midfield.
Garden saws in the test
For tree care work, the saws are usually stowed after cutting in a supplied booklet that can be attached to the trouser belt
Garden saws, also known as saber saws, are significantly larger than folding saws and are therefore also suitable for stronger branches and for cutting smaller trees. The saw blades are usually between 35 and 50 centimeters long and the cutting edge is either straight or slightly curved. On some models, the blade ends with a hook bent downwards. On the one hand it prevents the branch saw from slipping out of the cut, and it can also be used to pull larger cut branches out of the tree crown with the saw. Depending on the model, saber saws have different handle shapes: from simple, straight or curved bar handles with and without finger lugs to fully enclosed handles.
If you want to clear up large treetops without climbing the ladder, a saber saw is usually used on the telescopic handle. Different manufacturers offer models that can be used as normal saber saws as well as with the extension bar. This also allows you to reach the inaccessible areas right down to the top of the tree without having to climb the ladder. Very important also in these models is a so-called clearance hook, which is located either at the tip of the saw blade or at the lower end just behind the handle. When buying a telescopic saw, make sure that you can use the device with and without extension. In addition, the connection between telescopic rod and saw handle must be sufficiently stable.
Bahco branch saw 5128-JS
The Bahco 5128-JS is a newly developed, professional pruning saw for quick, effortless work in living, green wood with extremely sharp and aggressive, patented teeth. This so-called JS toothing with 45° cutting angle has large interdental spaces for transporting the wood chips. However, our testers were not entirely convinced of this because the saw blade tended to tilt repeatedly in the tests.
The two-component handle of the Bahco 5128-JS is a bit short
The Bahco 5128-JS can be worn on the belt with a patented holster. The saw is simply dumped in or out. Unfortunately this did not work for all testers without problems. It is good that the belt clip can be easily detached from the holster by turning and can be used by both left and right-handers. The extra leg strap with Velcro closure for more security and firmer hold is only available as an accessory. A manual is unfortunately not available in the shelf packaging in the trade. But you get several clicks on the website for a more detailed product overview.
The Bahco 5128-JS has a saw blade length of 280 mm and weighs 300 grams. She receives a "good" from our testers with a total score of 2.2. Its price is in the upper third of the test field.
Berger Handsaw 64850
The Berger Handsaw 64850 with replaceable high-performance hard-chromed carbon steel saw blade is designed for a long service life. Quality and ease of use are top. The triple ground tooth tips work only on train and slide with minimal resistance through the branch. This allowed our testers a precise, clean cut. The clean cut minimizes the wound surfaces and reduces the risk of infection by fungi or bacteria. The smoothing of the bark with the knife is ideally superfluous.
The Berger Handsaw 64850 works on train
The ergonomically shaped handle of the Berger Astsäge fits well in the hand. The quiver is attached to the belt with a click fastener. Optimal our testers would still find a thigh strap. A user manual is printed on the shelf packaging in the form of small pictograms. There are several clicks on the website for more information.
The Berger 64850 has a saw blade length of 330 mm and weighs 400 grams. Our testers gave her the overall score of 1.4, a "very good". Price is the Berger in the upper midfield.
Connex TurboCut branch saw
The Connex TurboCut saw has a razor-sharp saw blade, which made the first tester immediately unpleasant acquaintance, as it slid out of the packaging unprotected and damaged his finger. A protective quiver is also not available as an accessory. That's why you have to carry the TurboCut very carefully with you.
Connex TurboCut is also available with a 150 mm saw blade
But that was also the case with the negative impressions, because the Connex TurboCut did not have any weaknesses in terms of workmanship. Both in fresh and dry wood, our testers always achieved a smooth and clean cut. Also, the saw blade never stuck once. An instruction manual can not be found in the shelf packaging in trade - just a danger warning because of the sharp saw blade. There are several clicks on the manufacturer's website for more information.
The Connex TurboCut has a saw blade length of 320 millimeters and weighs 340 grams.From the ratings of the various testers, the overall score was 1.9, so a "good". With her price she is in the lower midfield.
Test winner: Felco F630 branch saw
The curved Felco F630 with pulling cut is one of the best quality branch saws in this high class environment. She showed almost no weaknesses. The sturdy chrome-plated steel blade always ensured a clean, precise cut and hardly led to signs of fatigue even in continuous use. If necessary, all components are easily interchangeable.
With the "soft-touch" handle, the Felco 630 sits well in the hand
The Felco 630 is stored in a holster with an innovative mechanical system that allows the saw to be easily and safely removed and replaced. A belt to attach the saw to the leg is part of the basic equipment. The instruction manual is extensive and in many languages in the shelf packaging commercially available. Further information on the product is not provided by the Swiss manufacturer on its website.
The Felco 630 has a saw blade length of 330 mm and weighs 400 grams. With a total score of 1.3, a "very good", she is one of the two test winners in the segment of garden saws, With a price of 56 euros, it is in the upper third.
Test winner: Fiskars SW-330
Fiskars calls the SW-330 a profes